This Cookie Dough Cake is pure FUN. Fun to make, fun to look at, and best of all–fun to eat! Cookie dough might just be the greatest un-cooked, yet edible food ever. Growing up, cookie dough ice cream was notoriously forbidden for us (cuz raw eggs are so scary 🙄) but once we could make our own grown-up ice cream decisions (sometimes dinner is simply ice cream around these parts 🤠) , we more than made up for lost time. Putting cookie dough into a cake, though, is pure genius, which I must credit to the talented @butternutbakery, who created this indulgent cookie-lover’s treat. Once I saw it, I knew I had to make it, and with my brother’s birthday coming up–he loves cookies, he loves cookie dough–it was the prime opportunity–HE ATE HALF THE CAKE (wew).Â
Every element of this cookie-packed cake is purely crafted to create one immaculate whole. The cake itself is a beautiful buttery vanilla cake with a crumb that is soft, yet sturdy enough to carry not only a generous sprinkle of mini chocolate chips, but also massive globs of cookie dough. And wow, the cookie dough! It’s got no egg in it, so feel free to sample away. It’s really such a simple and amazing brown sugary recipe that I want to have on hand for ice cream add-ins and general snacking purposes. The way it slightly caramelizes into the cake layers as they bake together infuses the cake with that beautiful molasses flavor, then solidifies once the cake is cooled to add a surprise of fun texture while you’re cutting into each layer.Â
Lastly the brown sugar-based buttercream is the kicker that brings it all together. WHY ISN’T BROWN SUGAR USED IN ALL FROSTINGS? Cuz, wow it adds the most amazing depth of flavor to the buttercream that is beyond just sweet. It also lends a lovely golden hue to the frosting, giving the cake a really appetizing and warm look. Also, mini chocolate chips are my new favorite thing. They are delightful in every component of this cake and should be used more often. Of course, the mini globs of cookie dough all over the top of this cake were the perfect finishing touch, which Little diligently picked off and took care of before I even finished eating my slice.
I decided to forego the chocolate ganache topping featured in Butternut Bakery’s version of this cake, purely for personal preference and I don’t think it was missed. It looks lovely, but I don’t think we could have enjoyed this cake any more–not possible. Needless to say, this cake was a hit; birthday boy 👽 was very pleased and had so much fun eating his massive slab as his celebratory decadence for the day. Happy Birthday, bro.