This is kind of a trick cookie. You know when you see an oatmeal raisin cookie and think it’s chocolate chip before biting into it? You can totally prank someone who hates oatmeal raisin cookies with this. Only they’ll be really happy about it. I have another cookie for that kind of scenario, the golden raisin oatmeal cookie.
While it seems deceiving, this cookie is pretty straightforwardly great. The base cookie dough is a solid buttery, brown sugary foundation with a chewy center and crisp edges. The classic flavor is elevated with the ever-so-smooth touch of Sir Skippy Peanut Butter. The whole oats add a pleasant and noninvasive bite. And the chocolate chips obviously have to be there anytime peanut butter is involved. Seems like a lot going on, but it’s actually a simple and fun way to amp up a textbook cookie. Definitely no complaints when a batch of these (shortly) lives in the cookie jar around here.